Mallaig Harbour Authority has warned the Scottish Parliament that a replacement ferry could enter service in 2029 or 2030, several years before the harbour improvements intended to accommodate the next generation of vessels are scheduled to begin.
In written evidence presented to the Scottish Parliament’s Transport Committee on 18 November, the authority said a proposed new breakwater and ferry quay would cost more than £100 million. However, the harbour’s upgrading programme is currently placed in the 2031–2036 phase of the Scottish Government’s draft Vessels and Ports Plan.
The replacement for MV Lord of the Isles, which serves the Mallaig–Lochboisdale route, is expected to enter service in late 2029 or early 2030.
Mallaig Harbour Authority is asking ministers to bring its harbour works forward and provide funding for a joint business case with Transport Scotland and Caledonian Maritime Assets Limited (CMAL).
The authority says the existing infrastructure is approaching 40 years old and cannot fully accommodate the planned replacement vessels without changes to berthing arrangements.
One Vehicle-Loading Linkspan Serves the Harbour
Mallaig handles ferry services connecting mainland Scotland with Skye, South Uist, the Small Isles and the Knoydart peninsula.
The harbour supports up to 25 ferry movements a day, with passenger vehicles and commercial traffic relying on a single vehicle-loading linkspan.
A linkspan is the movable bridge connecting a ferry’s vehicle deck to the shore, allowing vehicles to drive on and off as tides change.
At Mallaig, there is no second linkspan available to take over if the existing facility becomes unusable.
The harbour authority’s evidence reports that 249,801 CalMac passengers travelled through Mallaig in 2025, making it the sixth-busiest port in the ferry operator’s network.
The port also handles fishing vessels, aquaculture cargoes, private marine transport and visiting yachts.
Its 2024 economic impact assessment estimated that harbour activities supported £15.5 million in gross value added and 249 full-time-equivalent jobs.
These activities share harbour infrastructure, although their operational requirements differ.
£40 Million Alternative Would Leave Harbour Without Backup Berth
The harbour authority examined a lower-cost option involving repairs and alterations to the existing facilities.
Estimated at approximately £40 million, the work would strengthen the current breakwater, modernise the protective fenders used when vessels berth and realign the existing linkspan.
However, it would not provide a second vehicle-loading berth or additional terminal, marshalling and freight facilities.
The harbour authority also warned that construction affecting the existing linkspan could cause substantial disruption to ferry services.
There is no alternative local port arrangement capable of maintaining the same level of service during an extended closure, according to its submission.
The authority’s preferred project is a new breakwater quay in the outer harbour.
The proposal would provide a ferry berth and linkspan capable of accommodating vessels up to 105 metres long, together with a concrete slip for ferries fitted with ramps.
It would also provide an alternative to the existing linkspan.
Harbour Plans Have Been Developing Since 2016
Mallaig’s proposed new breakwater is not a recently introduced project.
The harbour’s masterplan, developed in 2016–2017, identified a new breakwater quay as the preferred option.
A Scottish Transport Appraisal Guidance study published in 2020 also examined options for upgrading the harbour.
Since then, plans for replacement ferries have progressed, while the harbour development has remained in a later investment period.
The authority says the new breakwater has been discussed with Transport Scotland, CMAL and CalMac.
Most of the estimated construction expenditure would involve rock armour and infill required to create and protect the new harbour facilities.
A smaller project has already received public investment. Transport Scotland funded a £6.4 million overnight ferry berth intended to improve existing arrangements and support future works.
That project does not provide the full facilities proposed in the harbour masterplan.
Harbour Authority Cannot Finance the Project Alone
Mallaig is a statutory trust port established in 1968.
It has no shareholders, does not receive routine public subsidy and reinvests its operating surpluses in harbour facilities.
Its turnover was £2.04 million in 2025–2026, compared with the estimated breakwater construction cost of more than £100 million.
The harbour authority says it cannot finance the development from its own resources.
Trust ports cannot raise money by issuing shares in the manner of conventional private companies. Major investment therefore generally depends on borrowing, grants or other funding arrangements.
The authority has requested a partnership arrangement defining contributions, ownership and responsibility for the proposed infrastructure.
It also wants the project moved from Phase 3 of the draft Vessels and Ports Plan into Phase 2.
The requested change would bring the harbour investment programme closer to the planned introduction of the replacement ferry.
Further Replacement Ferries Are Being Considered
The Lord of the Isles replacement is not the only future vessel change affecting Mallaig.
Discussions have begun concerning replacement vessels for MV Lochnevis and MV Coruisk, which operate services involving the Small Isles and Skye.
Future vessel dimensions, loading arrangements and overnight berthing requirements will influence the harbour’s infrastructure needs.
The harbour authority says that planning individual vessel replacements separately from port investment could result in repeated alterations to facilities rather than a coordinated construction programme.
Its submission also identifies the time required to obtain a Harbour Revision Order and marine licence before major construction can begin.
The Scottish Government must now consider whether to change Mallaig’s position in the investment programme and how the proposed breakwater might be funded.
Without a change to the timetable, the replacement Lord of the Isles is expected to enter service before the harbour’s major upgrading works are scheduled for delivery.
Sources
Ports, Harbour Infrastructure and Ferries — Written Evidence, Including Mallaig Harbour Authority Submission
Scottish Parliament Transport Committee, 18 November 2026
https://www.parliament.scot/~/media/committ/13829/Paper-1.-Ports-harbour-infrastructure-and-ferries
Transport Committee, 12th Meeting — Agenda
Scottish Parliament, 18 November 2026
https://www.parliament.scot/chamber-and-committees/committees/current-and-previous-committees/session-7/transport-committee/meetings/2026/transport-committee-18-november-2026/agenda




